2013 historical drama, first in a five-book series. Berlin, 1933:
Clara Vine, unsuccessful actress, has gone to Berlin to try her luck
in film, just as Hitler has come to power. She finds herself falling
upwards into the company of Magda Goebbels, and is recruited as an
intelligence source.
This is another book that makes its historical research
prominent, with lots of detail about the opening months of 1933 in
Berlin. And as far as I can tell it's mostly accurate, though a
reference to Currywurst (a post-war invention, which got its genesis
from curry powder supplied by the BAOR) leaves me suspicious about the
rest. Thynne does sometimes go on a bit, though, and some of the
descriptions start to feel like padding.
All the Nazis, and all the others who agree with them even slightly,
are Bad People, and this gets rather heavy-handed. It's not that I
want to read about how wonderful they were, but I could have used a
bit of nuance; where's the person who joined the Party out of genuine
conviction, or because he wanted to get ahead in the face of a
sclerotic system of promotion by family connections, and now finds
himself part of blatant thuggery? The emphasis is, deliberately,
mostly on the women's stories, and they do get a bit of variation in
character; Thynne sometimes manages to make Magda Goebbels almost
sympathetic (her initial idea for the book was apparently "what's it
like to be married to a monster"), though she occasionally drops into
bathos.
But Clara felt sure that gardening was not uppermost on Magda
Goebbels' mind.
All the historical infodumping does get a bit Lifestyles of the Rich
and Nazi, as we are dragged along to yet another ghastly meeting of
horrible people, with Clara largely a passive observer. Several
chapters deal not with Clara or her handler, but with other characters
who are in a better position to talk about what's happening in Germany
but who aren't really a part of the actual story; and the fictional
characters are mostly two-dimensional, with little about them that
can't be summed up in a few words ("brutal Nazi who likes to appear
cultured", "girl reporter who wants to do the big stories"). There
might be interesting things to say about the Deutsches Modeamt,
Hitler's attempt to have a proper German fashion movement just as he
was encouraging the creation of proper German music, film and so on,
and which was as much as a failure as one would expect from any
creative organisation where ideology came first… but this book doesn't
say them. The sex-and-shopping story tries to turn into a spy thriller
of the tawdry, dirty sort, but its heart isn't really in it. Most of
the plot elements are left unresolved for future books.
It's… OK, I suppose. But it never quite caught fire for me, and I
don't plan to read more in the series. Followed by The Winter Garden
(UK) / Woman In The Shadows (US).
Comments on this post are now closed. If you have particular grounds for adding a late comment, comment on a more recent post quoting the URL of this one.