2011 steampunk fantasy. The misfit crew of the Ketty Jay has fame,
at least a bit of fortune, and a new and exciting job… oh dear.
In terms of character development, Retribution Falls introduced
each character and showed us why they're on the crew. The Black Lung
Captain started to give them a bit of depth. This one, alas, is
rather more about marking time: two of the crew have troubled
relationships with women, both of which might work better if they
could just work out that other people are not merely transactional
devices to be loaded up with stuff in the good times so that they will
dispense what you want when life gets tougher again. But they do not
start to work this out; all they can think of to do, when they don't
get what they want, is to grovel at the boots of the mysterious
unknowable thing that is Woman. Various other people go through their
contortions but don't really get anywhere. What should be an arc for
Silo, the complicated ex-slave, turns out to leave him more or less
where he started.
‘My point is…’ Crake replied, then cringed as another volley of
bullets chipped along the tiles and turned a nearby cushion into a
cloud of feathers. ‘My point is, I’ve noticed a certain lack of
healthy cowardice in you recently, Cap’n. And I’m concerned it’s
going to get someone killed before long. Specifically, me.’
But apart from that it's good fun. There's plenty of action,
starting with a train robbery that goes horribly wrong, and ending in
an ancient city, and at all times you can work out who's where and
what's going on. If characterisation isn't deep, it's at least kept to
consistently, so the ultra-cowardly guy doesn't suddenly get a streak
of heroism when it's his turn to shine; instead he gets to do his
thing by virtue of being cowardly.
It's not great writing. But it's good writing, it's competent
writing, it doesn't leave you floundering and wondering what the hell
happened or why he said that. This isn't a book or a series that I'm
ever going to rave about, but I certainly found it worth the time I
spent reading.
Comments on this post are now closed. If you have particular grounds for adding a late comment, comment on a more recent post quoting the URL of this one.